Challenges:
Rutgers has challenged 19 times, winning 1:
- Nov 6, 1869 Rutgers 6:4 Princeton
- Nov 12, 1870 Rutgers 2:6 Princeton
- Nov 16, 1872 Rutgers 1:4 Princeton
- Nov 18, 1874 Rutgers 0:6 Princeton
- Nov 2, 1880 Rutgers 0:8 Princeton
- Oct 15, 1881 Rutgers 0:3 Princeton
- Nov 10, 1881 Rutgers 0:1 Princeton
- Oct 14, 1882 Rutgers 0:5 Princeton
- Nov 14, 1882 Rutgers 0:3 Princeton
- Nov 6, 1883 Rutgers 0:92 Yale
- Oct 22, 1884 Rutgers 10:76 Yale
- Oct 12, 1887 Rutgers 0:30 Princeton
- Oct 6, 1888 Rutgers 0:65 Yale
- Oct 8, 1890 Rutgers 0:27 Princeton
- Sep 25, 1948 Rutgers 6:27 Columbia
- Oct 4, 1952 Rutgers 19:61 Princeton
- Sep 8, 2001 Rutgers 0:61 Miami
- Nov 2, 2002 Rutgers 17:42 Miami
- Nov 16, 2019 Rutgers 21:56 Ohio State