Challenges:
Amherst has challenged 15 times, winning 0:
- Nov 2, 1878 Amherst 0:2 Yale
- Nov 16, 1878 Amherst 0:0 Yale
- Oct 19, 1888 Amherst 0:39 Yale
- Nov 10, 1888 Amherst 0:70 Yale
- Oct 19, 1889 Amherst 0:42 Yale
- Nov 12, 1889 Amherst 0:32 Yale
- Nov 11, 1891 Amherst 0:27 Yale
- Oct 19, 1892 Amherst 0:29 Yale
- Oct 18, 1893 Amherst 0:46 Yale
- Oct 21, 1896 Amherst 0:14 Pennsylvania
- Oct 11, 1899 Amherst 0:41 Harvard
- Oct 10, 1900 Amherst 0:18 Harvard
- Oct 2, 1901 Amherst 0:6 Yale
- Oct 8, 1902 Amherst 0:6 Harvard
- Nov 3, 1906 Amherst 0:21 Swarthmore